| 8¹ | BENAYOUN beat a number of Torino players and stroked an effort over the bar. |
| 11¹ | A fine run was ended by a good save by the oncoming PICKFORD. |
| 17¹ | A shot from LLORENTE held little difficulty for the New York 'keeper. |
| 22¹ | The 'keeper saved a lovely shot from ALTIDORE. |
| 23¹ | GUERREIRO scuffed a simple chance. |
| 25¹ | A twenty-five yard drive from REUS caused ROBLES no problem. |
| 26¹ | TAH dribbled away from JOHNSON and rifled a tame shot past the post. |
| 30¹ | A left foot shot from GUERREIRO was clawed past the post by the New York 'keeper. |
| 39¹ | A accurate pass fell to GABRIEL PAULISTA and his looping shot went narrowly wide. |
| 2² | BENAYOUN shot wide. |
| 5² | WANYAMA headed just beyond the far post. |
| 11² | A poor strike from KRAJNC rolled agonisingly wide. |
| 14² | WANYAMA was put clear by PAROLO and he beat the 'keeper but thrust his shot inches over. |
| 16² | LLORENTE's shot was well held by ROBLES. |
| 20² | PAROLO clipped the ball through a ruck of players but the Torino 'keeper was a match for it as he dived to his right. |
| 23² | BONUCCI flicked a left foot shot just beyond the near post from thirty yards out. |
| 25² | ALTIDORE steamed through the Torino defence but shot straight at PICKFORD. |
| 31² | A free-kick from ALTIDORE went just beyond the near post. |
| 32² | A shot from PAROLO was smothered by the 'keeper. |
| 38² | GOAL!! A long clearance by the New York 'keeper beat the Torino defence and ALTIDORE blasted the ball past the oncoming 'keeper. (1-0 New York)| 41² | ROBLES saved a glorious shot from IAGO. | | 42² | REUS's shot beat ROBLES but rebounded off the New York woodwork. | | 46² | GOAL!! Some neat work by KRAJNC on the left, left OLAITAN yards clear, and he raced past ROBLES and drove the ball into the back of the net. (1-1) | |