(2-1 Catania)| 22¹ | KEKO beat GIOVANI and whacked the ball to BURAK who fired his shot wide. |
| 24¹ | The motionless 'keeper stared in disbelief as a backpass from ALDERWEIRELD dropped just wide. |
| 32¹ | VÍLLA shot over. |
| 35¹ | A good ball from PJANIC on the left found CASTRO who mishit his effort over. |
| 41¹ | The 'keeper saved a curling shot from JOHNSON. |
| 43¹ | The 'keeper dived to his right to block an accurate shot from New York's BENAYOUN. |
| 45¹ | RAFAEL beat two New York players and slammed a great chance just wide. |
| 47¹ | VÍLLA placed a right foot shot wide from close range. |
| 2² | BENAYOUN stroked an easy chance past the far post. |
| 15² | A free-kick from DE PAUL raced wide. |
| 17² | A cross from CASTRO left DE PAUL in lots of space but he scuffed his shot. |
| 21² | GIOVANI made space on the left and pulled the ball to ALTIDORE who clipped the ball over. |
| 29² | BURAK headed over. |
| 38² | CASTRO scuffed a simple chance. |